How to Help Two Friends Reconnect: The Friendship Bridge
How to Help Two Friends Reconnect: The Friendship Bridge
Can you help two friends reconnect—or should you stay out of it?
In this episode of Slightly Unsupervised, Jennifer and Jackie talk about becoming a “friendship bridge” when two people who once loved each other have stopped speaking. Sometimes the friendship isn't really over. Pride, hurt feelings, misunderstandings, life circumstances, or simply too much time can leave both women waiting for the other to make the first move.
Jennifer and Jackie share real stories of helping friends find their way back, what worked, what definitely didn't, and the signs that two people may still miss each other. They also talk about when to stay out of it, why surprise reunions are usually a terrible idea, and one rule worth remembering: open the door, then get out of the doorway.
Because sometimes a best friendship doesn't need someone to fix it. It just needs someone to remind both people that the door may still be open.
This episode of Slightly Unsupervised was brought to you by the creators of Bestiemony®—the original friendship ceremony that proves soulmates don’t always come with a marriage license. Hosted by Jennifer and Jackie: best friends, business partners, and co-founders of the movement celebrating real, ride-or-die love.
💍 Book a Bestiemony: rhinestoneweddingchapel.com/bestiemony
📱 Follow us on Instagram at @Bestiemonies
📩 Got a bestie story to share or a subject request? Email us at [email protected]
unknown: Okay.
Jennifer: Hey there, I'm Jennifer. And I'm Jackie. Welcome to Slightly Unsupervised. We're best friends, business partners, and the chaos behind Bestimony, a ceremony we created to celebrate the kind of soulmates who don't come with the marriage license.
Jackie: This podcast is all about friendship, the deep stuff, the messy stuff, and the laugh until you snort stuff.
Jennifer: So whether you're driving, folding laundry, hiding in your car for some peace and quiet.
Jackie: We're so glad you're here. Let's get slightly unsupervised. Okay, today, the friendship bridge. Can we help two friends find their way back? Have you ever been friends with two women who used to be incredibly close and now they don't speak? And you're standing somewhere in the middle thinking, you two love each other, you both miss each other, and neither of neither one of you is going to make the first move. So what do we do as the friend on the outside? Do we stay out of it completely? Do we encourage one of one of them to reach out?
Jackie: Can we help clear up a misunderstanding? Or does trying to bring two friends back together cross a line that isn't ours to cross? Today we're talking about whether we can sometimes be a bridge between two people who have lost their way to each other and how to help without becoming part of the problem.
Jennifer: Um I picked this episode because we have, since we've started doing our little podcast, we have been Jackie and I have been involved in one friendship reconciliation, which we're proud of. And I just recently was in another one with my my sister and a friend of hers. So and they're actually meeting this weekend. She they both have, you know, confirmed they're gonna meet with each other. So I'm excited that we got to bring some people back. Um, Jackie and I will talk about the one that we kind of went through when we were in Vegas last year.
Jennifer: We were podcasting and we had a friend come podcast with us, and we knew a friend of hers, who's actually one of my best friends, that they were in a, I don't know, a disagreement or not a disagreement. I think that's just they just hadn't talked in a long time, right? They hadn't talked, politics were kind of coming into that one a little bit. So, and I remember Jackie and I both being like so dumb. They were such good friends that neither one of them, you know, hadn't seen each other in a long, long bit of time, I guess, but hadn't stayed close enough to reconciliate that a little bit.
Jennifer: So Jackie and I just kind of slowly I kind of worked on my best friend and we kind of got them into a position where they And they were both asking, remember?
Jackie: They were both asking about how the other one was doing. So we're kind of getting the f the feel that they did still care about each other, that they probably might be interested in getting back together, right? Like talking to each other. Right. We weren't really sure, but we were kind of thinking, hey, they wouldn't ask about the other one if they didn't care, right? Oh, totally, yeah.
Jennifer: But it was hard because we didn't want to put ourselves in a position either, right? Jackie, we didn't want to put our position because we were friends with both of them. And we were seeing the one, and and I'm obviously you know still very good friends, you are too with the other one. So we didn't want to get like it's hard to know. It's hard to know in those situations. Do we jump in? Do we facilitate something? I mean, I know we both we both kind of walked into it slowly. I mean, I think in the back of our when we were having conversations behind the scenes, we're like, we're gonna get them back together, they belong together, they're friends, there's no reason for them not to be friends.
Jennifer: So, you know, we sort of just made little seedlings, we little plants of information to the other one to see if we could jar them to come back together as friends. And it worked. It did. I think part of it is, you know, you've got to be careful because you gotta you gotta really know when you wanna be involved and when you don't want to be involved, because you can get yourself in the middle of that, right? We've probably had that happen between us, not maybe in this instance, but we have you know, you learn your lesson when you get involved with people that are not talking to each other and you try to bridge them together.
Jackie: Yeah, because that one could have went wrong. It could have, yeah. On one side. Once I think one person could have went kind of off the little bit, you know.
Jennifer: I think in that instance she needed a little bit of encouragement that maybe she was thinking the wrong thing. Maybe she had created a image in her head that wasn't correct. Um I think when we got that one back together, that was part of it, was that they had, you know, one had again, you've we've talked about this time thing. I know we just did a a podcast on it, but when you have enough time, enough time comes, you build enough scenarios in your head, right? The narrative gets louder and louder about, you know, well, she didn't call me and she didn't call me and she did this and she did that.
Jennifer: You just get yourself worldworked up into a position of, you know, we'll never be friends again. And there really hadn't been anything going on. Either one of them probably let the other one kind of rest and figure out what they were doing. And so then they turned in it turned into an explosion. And time does that with things. So it's important to, but be a bridge, not a messenger. So uh this is one of the we're just kind of reading out the things it tells us not to do. It's true. We were kind of a bridge.
Jennifer: We did we did we did relay messages back and forth a little bit, but we were more, I don't know, in a position of just trying to let the other one see, maybe, you know, and give this an opportunity again. Maybe you're wrong about this, but in a nice way, right? That says, you know, you may have come to the wrong conclusion on this particular situation. So and don't feed anger, Lord, don't do that. Cause had we done that, Jack, we would have never gotten anywhere with it. Because when you feed anger, you know, you get yourself into a bind with that because now you're picking sides, so sides picking can be.
Jennifer: Yeah, no, thank you. No, thank you. Now you're part of the problem too, right? When you get into that. So it's not easy to do. And, you know, you can downplay the anger sometimes. I know in the instance we're talking about, you know, one side of this equation is just reactionary, you know, it's a reaction of our childhood, a reaction of all things, and it's like just let her simmer down a little bit and then have a more reasonable conversation. You definitely don't do it in the height of the trigger, but that's a better word, trigger.
Jennifer: When they're getting triggered, you do not that is not the time to negotiate, you know, any sort of yeah. You gotta wait for the trigger to kind of m go down and then go, well, let's look at it maybe a little bit differently today. So that's what happened. Um, and you know they miss each other. You know it. We knew it. It was happening. And when we were in the middle of it, that's when we were just saying we knew the other one was missing the other one because of the way they asked about each other.
Jennifer: So that is a good indication that maybe there's some hope there. Uh but no surprise reunions, I'll give you that. Do not bring two people together that are not in the ingredients to meet with each other, right?
Jackie: So yes, not a good idea. Not a good idea. I've done that, and it's I mean, it worked out all right, but it still was it's awkward, it's just not worth it. I was young, it's just not a good idea. Just stay out of it.
Jennifer: That's the thing you learn, right? And at their age is like, you know, bringing them together when they don't know they're gonna be around each other can be very uncomfortable for everybody, including you. So I do not suggest surprise reunions. And, you know, if they do re- reconnect, you gotta get out of the way. Let them be. So I just recently went through this. I'll just give you a little backstory because I think stories are good for for understanding them. But my sister had a friend and uh they were really close, and I kept seeing the friend after they got into some sort of TIFF.
Jennifer: And I don't even know what the TIFF was about. I don't get that deep into it. I don't even think it was that major. I just think the other one said the other one didn't call, and so they got themselves worked up into a situation where it was the other one's fault, but really nothing happened. Really hard to negate it's really hard to negotiate something when you don't really figure out what happened. What happened here? Nothing really happened. So, anyways, the one my sister's friend went in for surgery, and so she texts me after the surgery to let me know how it went.
Jennifer: It was a pretty major surgery, it was a heart surgery. And so very quietly I just sent it to my sister. I'm like, oh, just FYI. I didn't know if he knew about this. So I knew my sister read it. And of course, when somebody's had surgery and it went well, but it had some hiccups, there was some scary parts to it. I knew that if there was any gonna be any way for them to reconcile, it was gonna be in that because that's a good time. That's when your defenses are down, when you can reach off to somebody and say, I hope you're doing okay.
Jennifer: I heard about it. You know, it's kind of a in this instance, it was a nice, it was a nice lead-in. So nobody had to be on a defense. It was something about her health. And I know my sister, I knew my sister would respond to it. I just and I just sent it to her and I didn't say much. And then I saw my sister this weekend and she's like, We're gonna have lunch this week, or I made contact with her, and I was like, Oh, good, you know, so trying to stay out of it a little bit, but also very curious to make sure that they reconnect.
Jennifer: But it was an opening, right? There's some opening sometimes where you can do that. And we had an opening in Vegas that we could do that too, right? It wouldn't have worked if we were just on a Tuesday and decided these two should be friends and didn't really have any, you know, any way to reconnect them. So, you know, play your cards right, I guess, is the best way if you have a card to play. You were talking about Jackie when you were trying to reconcile somebody and that didn't work out well because you put them together.
unknown: Yeah.
Jackie: Did it work? We were a lot younger, it was way different.
Jennifer: I know. But did they did they end up reconciling, or was it one of those things you probably for the evening?
Jackie: I think it it turned out all right. It was just, you know, at first just awkward. I didn't tell them I was gonna I picked them both up and put them in a car together. And probably I'm sure they both didn't appreciate it the time. I mean, now we can laugh about it. Uh-huh. But I think at that time, and I think I'm sure for a while after that they didn't appreciate it at all. Especially when I think back now. I would have been so angry if someone did that with me. Right. I just thought I was being the good friend, and but we're all what, you know, the three musketeers.
Jackie: Let's go. We gotta go out together. It's New Year's Eve. Come on. We can get over this, you know.
Jennifer: Yeah. But they played along, but that didn't long-term work out for I don't think so.
Jackie: I mean, they I they're they they they talk to each other and stuff, but I don't think it was ever gonna be a friendship like they had. Right. And I I thought it was gonna be, you know, back to the same old however thing was, and it wasn't. And I mean, that's that's to them. I mean, it's fine. I'm not friends with the one that any close to one anymore any either. So yeah, that one was going her own direction anyway. So it is what it is. But I feel like you tried to make me friends with one of our friends, and that didn't work out well.
unknown: Okay.
Jennifer: Is this the 30 is this the 30-year narrative that you had to work up 30 years to put put in your head that what happened there? And then I was like, Oh, you should be friends again. You're like, no. And I'm like, okay, you had 30 years to stew on a story, so I was like, okay, I'll stand on that one. But why wouldn't you? I mean, if you you know, sometimes you lose contact or something and you know somebody, you're like, hey, you remember so and so, and you try. I mean, I always try to make people friends.
Jennifer: I don't like it. I don't like to be in environments where people are not friends. That's an uncomfortable situation, right? So it's not uh it's not fun for anybody. So of course, if you can bridge it, then bridge it. If you can't, then you know, get in your car and go to the next spot. Be like, well, you two have fun. I'm going my way. But you know, you can't make everybody friends. Sometimes you don't even know, and that's part of this, right? You don't know really what happened. Right. We don't really know what happened.
Jennifer: I we both have, you know, said that we don't know really what happened with the two, and I don't know really what happened to my sister and her friend. I just know that they were at odds.
Jackie: And the and the two we're talking about too. The one, she's like you she had another chance with her because she had health issues and it was not good. I mean, right, you know, she was she was not good for a while. She could have went a different direction.
Jennifer: Yeah.
Jackie: She could have never reconciled with she, you know, might have not right been able to reconcile. So I'm really glad they did get to.
Jennifer: I'm really happy for them. And they've actually seen each other since then Yeah, they met up.
Jackie: They met up.
Jennifer: I think it's awesome. Yeah.
Jackie: So they they have a friendship again and and you know, we Yeah, so if it's somebody you think you're gonna regret, I mean if it's just something petty, do it. You know, and if you if it's a friend, two friends that you think it's petty and it's stupid, it's something over something like you're saying your sister just something because someone didn't call each other. Come on. Then I would in that situation I'd be like, come on, you guys. Like I try to fix, I try to get them back together. Definitely.
Jennifer: And I did. I mean, I was trying in that regard, and I was giving a lot of information because I know my sister obviously well and what's going on with her life, and so I'm like, eh, it's probably not a good time to contact her right now. It's a lot of stuff going on in her life, and then you know, I was trying to give her some some insight because I know they're really good friends. Not to, you know, not to backstab my sister or anything, just like trying to help her navigate that a little bit because I think my sister wanted to reconcile.
Jennifer: I just don't think my sister wanted to be the one to do it. How many times?
Jackie: Some people are really stubborn, yeah.
Jennifer: Yeah.
Jackie: But I mean, if it's something like if somebody was really mean to my child and I don't think they deserved it, I might have a little problem, you know. Yeah. Or or if like if somebody, like let's say two friends and one was really friend mean to the other ch person's children, then I'd understand, hey, I might not get involved in that situation and try to bring them back friends. Right. That's that's pretty personal. You know what I mean? Right. But like I said, something about a phone call or something weird.
Jackie: I'd be like, come on, let's get over it.
Jennifer: And politics right now, I mean, there's there's a lot of that.
Jackie: People, let's leave the politics out of it too.
Jennifer: So ridiculous. You're just like, how do you grow an old friend? How do you wreck how do you find somebody else that can have that history with you and that life with you and you know, remember things with you? Yeah. You let it all go over politics because you're standing up for your side. What it and your side is feeding you, you know, and getting you riled up and you better not do that and you better do this. Like, come on. Yeah, are they gonna be there for you? No, we were there, no, they're looking for a vote.
Jennifer: So politics, yeah, politics is terrible. It's been horrible. I've seen so many friends just you know, not friends anymore because of it. And what a silly, silly thing to do. Because if you really talk about politics with somebody that's on the other side and and have a friend that's on the other side of this, and we talk, we're not that far off, right? Things haven't really changed that much. It's the perception of what she thinks, and it's the perception of what my party thinks, and that we fight with each other.
Jennifer: We've you know, we've stuck we sidestep that because when we really do talk, we're not that far off. You know, most people are not looking to, you know, do terrible things to humans and and all the things.
Jackie: And if you're yeah, and if you're sensitive and you can't handle it, then don't talk about it. Yeah, don't just leave it out of your conversation, just leave it out.
Jennifer: Yeah. Be Dolly, people.
Jackie: Dolly Park never talked about it. Everybody loved Dolly. If you can't handle it, don't talk about it. That's uh how I see it.
Jennifer: Okay, so anyways, the friendship bridge rules don't choose sides, don't carry gossip, don't share private conversations without permission. Encourage them to talk directly. Good idea. And open the door and get out of the doorway, which we got out of the doorway and we just said we've done what we can. We'll just pray that that works out for these two. And it did. So good for us, Jack. Yeah. Patting myself on the back right now. That's me too. I got two under my belt this this year. Well, no, maybe one was last year, so whatever.
Jennifer: Anyways, be a bridge if you can. All right, so let's go to the best of rapid questions. Jack, I'll go first. Have you ever been stuck between two friends who were not speaking?
Jackie: Obviously, yes. And probably more, way more than this. I mean, right. Just I didn't deal with anything. Yes. We just didn't deal with the situation. Yeah. Okay. Would you want someone to tell you if a former friend misses you?
Jennifer: Yeah, I would. I don't hold on to anger. I'm not an angry person long term. Like you would find it real hard pressed for me finding about you I hate. Like, I still hate. I hate her. Like, I just I've let it go because I am one of those people for sure that will just look at the situation and be like, did it teach me something? Did I learn something? Did I grow from that? I can make peace with it and move on. It's not, it was meant to be, is what I kind of feel. Like I was meant to learn that lesson and I have.
Jennifer: So if you told me a former friend missed you, I would, yeah, I'd want you to tell me that. That'd be good because it opens a door, right? Like right. And you go from there. You go from there. All right, Jack. Have you ever been too stubborn to make the first move?
Jackie: Obviously. Yes.
Jennifer: It's me.
Jennifer: You know, I'm not doing that. We had that. You know, we Jackie and I have been all very open and honest about us being not friends for a long time. And probably some of that stubborn to make the first move probably came into play with some of that with us, just in just with us, right? So Yeah. I d I think we got we I think what happened is we came to an event that we were both in, and we it was, you know, universal and we were gonna work. And so that's how it kind of broke that a little bit to have us having conversations.
Jennifer: And it wasn't about our situation, it was just about something else. And so we got to go past it and talk about other things and then come back and be like, okay, we can maybe work on this. So it helped us, I think.
Jackie: So okay. Would you ever tell a friend I love you, but I think you're wrong here?
Jennifer: Yes. Yes. Why would you why would you want to say that, you know, I don't know. Yes, I would do that. Because you have to have growth, you have to still stand in your place of where you're at. So he was supposed to be honest.
Jackie: Um I'm not gonna do it in front of someone else, I'll do it private with that.
Jennifer: And it probably wouldn't be like mean and be like, I love you. I I don't think you're right, but that's okay. You can be who you what you think. I understand that stuff. I mean, not everything I think is right, but sometimes I'm not gonna move my opinion just because you do. So that's just being that's just being who you are. Okay, if two former best friends both privately told you they missed each other, what would you do, Jackie?
SPEAKER_01: Tell them both.
Jennifer: Like dial the phone. Like, hey, let me go into my car.
SPEAKER_01: So and so message you. Hey, so-and-so misses you. Let's come on, let's get this fruit ball rolling, let's get this all back together.
Jennifer: I know. And Jackie's like super social, so she's probably like, why don't you guys come over? We'll like do the pool, we'll hang out, I'll make snacks, and you guys I'll make dinner, we'll have a charcuterie board, we're gonna have lime.
SPEAKER_01: Oh, yes, you like corones with the lime, you get fat.
Jennifer: What do you like? Jackie would make the environment very cozy warm for everybody and be like, Oh, hi, aren't you? Glad you're here. And you don't you miss each other? Like, I know you would do that, and that's exactly who you are.
Jackie: All right. Okay. Has anyone ever helped you repair a friendship?
Jennifer: I guess so. I think there's there's always people that encourage. Maybe they don't do it like we didn't do it blatantly, but sort of nudge people into certain things that are behind the scenes or whatever. So I'm sure that there's been plenty of those, especially when we were younger, when we would fight with all each other amongst each other, whatever. People be like, You guys need to be friends again, you know, that kind of thing. So yeah. I think in our friendship repair between you and me, it needed us to do it.
Jennifer: And so I think everybody around it was fine with it and was encouraging, but I think everybody stayed out of it to let us repair it because we needed to repair it.
Jackie: People were scared to be part of that. Yeah, that way let them deal with this. Don't even touch it with a 10-foot bowl.
Jennifer: And that was wise, girls. It was wise. Stay out of it, let us figure it out.
Jackie: So okay. During the years we weren't speaking. If someone had tried to bring us back together, here we go. Would we have actually been ready?
Jennifer: Together many times. We saw each other for other events, so we would see each other. It wasn't an angry, it wasn't uh, we weren't like fighting. It wasn't like this bickering, it wasn't like we're ignoring each other. We just, it was a weirdness between us that wasn't this normal we had been. So I think it needed the time, don't you? I think we needed time. I need the time. Am I some? Oh, go ahead.
Jackie: And as long as I was with my ex-husband, it would have been hard to do. Right.
unknown: Yeah.
Jackie: Or the situation needed to change. Yeah, at least to get close again. We could have been friends, but like, you know, I I wasn't able to be close to any of my friends. Right.
unknown: Yeah.
Jackie: Which was a bummer. Like we couldn't be as close like we are again, like now. Right. Right. And that's environments with everybody. Yeah.
Jennifer: Yeah. It wasn't me. It was it wasn't specific. We could have been, we could have maybe made a attempt to be friends surface level, but it was never gonna be like like it is now because we couldn't, environment wasn't ready for that. We couldn't do that till it changed, and then it changed and then we were able to do it. So sometimes you gotta wait for the change. All right. Sometimes we look at two people who used to love each other to assume that if they wanted to be friends again, they would be.
Jennifer: But I'm not sure that's always true. Sometimes there's pride, sometimes there's fear, sometimes too much time has passed and nobody knows how to begin. And sometimes two women are sitting in completely different places, each believing the other one doesn't want it anymore. Maybe that's where the rest of us can come occasionally do some good. Not fix it, not force it, not decide who's right. Just remind someone that the door might not be as permanently closed as she thinks. Ask the question, do you miss her?
Jennifer: Encourage the phone call, offer the invitation, and then let someone decide. Because friendship ultimately belongs to two people inside of it. But every once in a while, maybe we're lucky enough to build a little bridge between two people who forget how to get back to each other. And if they cross it, let 'em. Because if two people genuinely loved each other, they find their way back, and friendships always win. If this conversation made you think about your person, call her, text her, take her to coffee, and tell her that she matters.
Jennifer: Because some of life's greatest love stories don't come with a marriage license.
Jackie: If you enjoyed today's episode, we'd be so grateful if you'd subscribe, leave us a review, and share it with your write or die best friend.
Jennifer: Want to see some of our incredible friendships we've celebrated? Visit our best amount of you. YouTube channel where women from all over the country share their stories of friendship and how it changed their lives.
Jackie: And if one day you'd like to celebrate your own friendship, we'd love to welcome you to Nashville.
Jennifer: Until next time, keep showing up, keep hearing each other on, keep celebrating the women who make your life better, and we'll see you next time on Slightly Unsupervised.
Song: We stick together, eye or die to the moon, and no amount of space could ever come between us two. The reuniting's like we've never been apart, and every single time we're eye to eye and heart a heart.
Song: Through heartaches and ups and downs in this life, you've stayed right next to me. I've ought to make you laugh till you cry.
Song: The definition of a best friend is you And we'll keep printing through the range. We're ever connected, same page, we're writing our story. Everything we'll keep on going, ever changing.
Song: What you made a made. Through heartaches and ups and downs in this life, you've stayed right next to me. I'll about to make you laugh till you cry.
Song: The definition of a first friend is you trust that loyalty.
Song: Love trust that says loyalty.
Podbean