Friendship Anxiety: Why We Assume Our Friends Are Mad at Us
Have you ever gotten a weird text from a friend and immediately thought, Is she mad at me? Or had her cancel plans and suddenly convinced yourself she’s pulling away?
Welcome to the stories we tell ourselves.
In this episode of Slightly Unsupervised, Jennifer and Jackie talk about what happens when we don’t have all the facts and our brains decide to fill in the blanks. A delayed text becomes rejection. A canceled lunch becomes proof we don’t matter. A different tone of voice becomes evidence that the friendship is falling apart.
And before we know it, we’re reacting to a story that may not even be true.
Jennifer and Jackie get into overthinking friendships, assumptions, past relationship wounds, conflict avoidance, friendship insecurity, and why our brains are so good at turning missing information into an entire imaginary storyline.
They also share one simple question that might save a friendship:
“Can I tell you the story I’m telling myself?”
Instead of accusing a friend, asking everyone else what they think she meant, or quietly deciding the friendship is over, what if we simply gave her the chance to tell us what’s actually going on?
In This Episode:
Why our minds fill in the blanks when something feels different [01:14]
Have we been overthinking friendships since grade school? [01:59]
How past hurt can follow us into new relationships [04:14]
When a friendship changes and we automatically assume we did something wrong [05:21]
Learning to laugh at some of the stories we create in our heads [06:40]
The question that could save a friendship: “Can I tell you the story I’m telling myself?” [07:15]
How to bring up a problem without immediately putting your friend on the defensive [08:22]
Why you have to be willing to discover that you were wrong [10:08]
Why you might NOT want to ask another friend what she thinks happened [10:41]
Giving people the benefit of the doubt—and a little grace [12:01]
Do you usually ask or assume? [13:06]
Why women overthink friendships [13:54]
The biggest mistake we make when we’re hurt [14:59]
One question that can help save a friendship [15:31]
Why assumptions feel like facts—even when they aren’t [16:13]
If you’ve ever replayed a conversation, analyzed a text message, wondered why she hasn’t called, convinced yourself someone was mad at you, or created an entire friendship crisis in your head without actually asking the other person what was going on—this episode is for you.
Our minds are incredible storytellers. Sometimes those stories protect us. Sometimes they prepare us. And sometimes they quietly steal relationships that never needed to end.
So before you decide she doesn’t care—ask.
Before you assume she’s angry—ask.
Before you convince yourself the friendship is over—ask.
Because sometimes a friendship doesn’t need all the answers. It just needs one honest conversation.
Follow Slightly Unsupervised wherever you listen to podcasts, leave us a review, and share this episode with the friend who has definitely received an “Are you mad at me?” text from you.
And visit Bestiemony® on YouTube to hear real women share the stories of the friendships that changed their lives.
Because some of life’s greatest love stories don’t come with a marriage license.
This episode of Slightly Unsupervised was brought to you by the creators of Bestiemony®—the original friendship ceremony that proves soulmates don’t always come with a marriage license. Hosted by Jennifer and Jackie: best friends, business partners, and co-founders of the movement celebrating real, ride-or-die love.
💍 Book a Bestiemony: rhinestoneweddingchapel.com/bestiemony
📱 Follow us on Instagram at @Bestiemonies
📩 Got a bestie story to share or a subject request? Email us at [email protected]
Jackie: Hey there, I'm Jennifer. And I'm Jackie, and welcome to Slightly Unsupervised. We're best friends, business partners, and the clo chaos behind Bestimony, a ceremony we created to celebrate the kind of soulmates who don't come with a marriage license. This podcast is all about friendship, the deep stuff, the messy stuff, and the laugh t until you snort stuff.
SPEAKER_01: Whether you're driving, folding laundry, hiding your c in your car for some peace and quiet.
Jackie: We're so glad you're here. Let's get slightly unsupervised. Okay, today we are talking about the stories we tell ourselves when friendship starts living in our heads. Have you ever convinced yourself someone was mad at you? Mm-hmm. Only to find out they weren't. Or assumed a friend was pulling away when she was actually just overwhelmed. Today we're talking about something I think almost every woman has done. We start writing stories in our heads. A delayed text becomes rejection. A cancelled lunch becomes proof we don't matter.
Jackie: A different tone of voice becomes a friendship that's falling apart. And before we know it, we believed a story we wrote ourselves. Today we're talking about why we do it, how it slowly changes our friendships, and what we can do before those stories become our truths.
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, honestly, I think this has ended more friendships than actual conflict because women do this all the time. Yeah. Oh yeah, I'm guilty. I'm not notorious for it. Yeah. I'm pretty guilty of it too, to be honest with you. Uh you know, we've we've talked about it before when we don't have the answers to a situation and our minds naturally fill in the places or fill in the missing pieces so that we can move past it. And if we don't have all the answers, we create our own answers or we create our own reality, and then we think that's the truth.
SPEAKER_01: And in the meantime, we've destroyed a friendship or relationship, even doesn't even have to be a friendship. And it's because the narrative in our head got a held of the situation rather than the actual truth. So I think the question is not that we don't do it, Jack. I think the question is is how do we stop doing that and give the person the respect to say, hey, is something different? Or am I imagining this or whatever? Why do we do that? Because I think it starts even in like grade school. I mean, I think it's just always been.
SPEAKER_01: Like, is it is it because we are taught to be quiet, to accept things more? That the only way for us to properly process something is potentially just creating a narrative so that we can continue processing and move on? Like, you know what I mean? Like, where does that start? Because can you think back to maybe when you were in grade school or I don't think we're yeah, well, I don't think we're moving on because we're trying to figure out what's going on.
Jackie: Right. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01: But I mean, do you yeah, but what what is it that c causes women to do it more than men? Like, do you remember doing this in like grade school too?
Jackie: Yeah. I remember trying to figure out why my friend playing with my other friend more than me. Like, what did I do? Like, hey, you're supposed to be playing with me right now. Why are you not in the handball court and over at the tether ball and you know, I don't want to play tetherball today? We're supposed to be playing handball. We're not eating at the benches, we're eating on the grass today, right?
SPEAKER_01: But do you think that like you stood there on the the tether ball or the handball court looking over and being like, well, it's because I beat her yesterday. That's clearly what's happened here. Like, you know what I mean? Like, just make up a narrative in your head and to be like, the reason we're not doing it the way I normally do it is because of this, right? We just assume. Or exactly, you know, we're not eating on the right piece of we're not eating in the right space because somebody got misinformed.
SPEAKER_01: Whatever it is, we make up a narrative and we don't ask. And I think that's one of our greatest downfalls is that if we could just like reasonably have conversations, we could probably sort out a lot of our issues with in particular women. I think too, and I'll be honest with you, when we do it in relationships with men, they're almost flabbergasted because we have a whole scenario that has occurred. We tell them eventually, because we get mad enough, and they stand there and their mouths drop open because they're like, What happened?
SPEAKER_03: Like, has that ever happened to you?
Jackie: They're like, Oh yeah, I can say her husband's like, What are you even talking about? And it's worse after and and it's really bad because I had a husband who who eventually I found out was cheating on me. And so I took that onto my next relationship. So I assumed, you know, within my next relationship that that's the kind of stuff that was happening. So in my head, so many things were going on. And my poor husband now had to deal with a lot of stuff where he's just looking at me like, what are you thinking?
Jackie: I know we're laughing about it. So far from that, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01: I know, I know we're laughing about it, but it's so true. Like, if you don't, and they say that too, right? If you don't stop process and put the places, put it in the places it needs to be, you will just move it into the next relationship. And of course, what you were just saying is like if he's that way, then you're that way, and therefore I don't trust you. And he hasn't done anything wrong. So no women, women, we need to stop doing this, and we all do it. No one's blaming you because evidently we've learned to do it, but it's it's really makes more messes than it it helps us.
SPEAKER_01: So sometimes it helps us. Sometimes I guess we can make the story good and move on, and it maybe it isn't as good, but we can put our mind at ease or something.
Jackie: So I guess a scenario can happen in friendships too. You could have a best friend that all of a sudden moved over to another friendship, and you're like, whatever happened to our friendship? So you're a little scared on getting close to someone, right? Because hey, this one friendship, I never found out why she left me and went all of a sudden we weren't so close anymore. I mean, so you gotta get a closure on that too to find out what happened. Right. What was it? Did I have bad breath? Did I what I do wrong?
SPEAKER_01: Did I not wear deodorant correctly? Something's happened here. I know, right?
Jackie: Why? Why did you go over with her?
Jackie: Did you ever call to ouse?
unknown: No.
SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
Jackie: What did you do?
SPEAKER_01: Made it the story in your head.
Jackie: Yep, exactly. So it's not like yes.
SPEAKER_01: You lost your best friend in sixth grade because you didn't brush your teeth.
SPEAKER_01: Now you obsessively brush your teeth when you go and hang out with new friends because you've now created a scenario, right? That it was your breath and that was the problem in there.
Jackie: And that makes you feel better. So if that works.
SPEAKER_01: Oh man, we are so jacked up.
Jackie: It's better than thinking of my personality, right? No.
SPEAKER_01: It wasn't certainly something I've done. I mean, I'm perfect in all regards, you know. So we do it. I mean, we're just making fun of it because you do have to you do first have to come to grips that you do it, and then you need to start really laughing at yourself about all the things you've made up in life and just give yourself credit for your creativity. None of it happened, you know. Right. And I I guess a real good way to decide if you do it or not is to have a conversation with your romantic other and see what gets out of them when they look at you and be like, I have no idea what you're talking about, because that is a good indication that you do this.
SPEAKER_01: So anyway, so I think that there's a really good sentence here that I think could help save a relationship. And I think it's a good one because if you got yourself into this and you've backed yourself into a corner and you're not talking to somebody or you've created a scenario in your head, I think this is a really nice lesson. And it says, can you to contact this person and be all, can I tell you the story I'm telling myself? Can I go over what I have created here? And can we just dissect this?
SPEAKER_01: Because it's a nice way, I feel like, to bring it up that isn't blaming anybody, right? If I asked you, Jack, can I can I tell you the story I'm telling myself? What is your first reaction? Like, are you feeling like threatened? Are you feeling like, okay, let me hear? Like, what's your reaction to that?
Jackie: Well, it just matters what it is. Cause it could be it's just something going on in my life, and so it's nothing to do with you.
Song: Yeah.
Jackie: So I could either feel sad for you or I could feel, you know what I mean? I'm so sorry I made you feel that way.
unknown: Right.
Jackie: Or it could be, you know what? Yeah, let's talk about this. If there is something, you know? Right. So I I think isn't a threatening. You brought it up. No, it wouldn't fit threatening to me, not at all. Not at all. You would be like, What? What did you what's going on?
SPEAKER_01: Like, I think you would come in and I just told you my story and started accusing you. You could see how that could almost end a relationship because you are coming at me in a different way. And also, I now think you're crazy because you may come back, you know, and I'd be like, I have no idea what you're talking about. Like you're insane. So it gives you kind of a nice way, I feel like, to come into something and just say, Can I tell you the story I'm telling myself so that we don't we can go over it and it's non-threatening?
SPEAKER_01: So, and I think a good friendship will do it. Be like, yeah, let's talk about it. I think when you get into a position where you've got a conflict with somebody, Jackie, can you think of ways like that you have tried to resolve that and have failed at it? That there's a lot of ways that we do that. And do we, you know, let's like some way like that someone's come at you that hasn't worked, or you came at somebody with a situation that didn't work. So we can't give an idea about I wouldn't do it that way.
SPEAKER_01: I would try this way better. I think that's a better way. But is it accusatory? Like, well, you just didn't do this or you didn't do that, or you know, you know how you're passive aggressive. In my mind, you probably put out some like jabbers, like little innuendos, like yeah.
Jackie: I kind of joke about it. Yeah is how I kind of do it. Yeah. To kind of make so that sometimes works and sometimes it doesn't. Because I'm kind of the person I I I have a hard time just getting to the point. You know what I mean? I just I don't like conflict. I'd rather not have any kind of conflict. I'd rather just I feel like everything's just gonna take care of itself, you know, eventually.
SPEAKER_01: So eventually, but if yeah, but if you're in a stuck position, you're gonna have to draw it to some way and be like, you know, either we're gonna get past it or we're gonna not get past it, or you know, like but I think that just coming to just coming to somebody maybe like, can I tell you with the scenario that's going on in my head right now? So maybe I'm wrong. Also be willing to be wrong. Also be willing to have it corrected, also be willing to hear the other side of that. Cause like you said, it could just be you're busy, it could be that something's happened.
SPEAKER_01: It it could legitimately be that you're mad at somebody for something, but you're not that man, you know what I mean? We're allowed to get mad at each other, irritated, and not have it.
Jackie: Let me get over it, yeah. Like something that someone just needs to get over.
SPEAKER_01: Yeah. Give them some time to do it. So be graceful on that. So, anyways, I think that that's a really good way. And if you've got yourself into a story that you believe that you're not really sure. Other ways that you can help others is ask questions before you make conclusions, separate the facts from the interpretations, don't ask uh another friend first. I gotta caution you on this, y'all. When you go to another friend and they might have a bias, or you go to another friend and they don't really care, or you go with another friend and start of hearing the story, they will lead you in the wrong direction because they're trying to end the conversation.
SPEAKER_01: Number one, or two, they're tired of hearing about it. So they'll agree that that's probably what happened. And then you have really worked yourself up into a whole see, they agree with me. And you're like, I didn't really care. That's why I agreed with you. I just didn't want you to stop talking about it. Could be the scenario, right? People do that. Like, I don't want to hear about this anymore. So yeah, you're right. That's what happened. And so then you've got, you know, fuel behind you. Because when you have a pack, when you're mad and you get a pack of people behind you, especially girls, we're all mad.
SPEAKER_01: They're not mad. You're mad. They're just trying to agree with you to shut you up, right? Have you ever done that? I've done that. But yeah, yeah, yeah, that's right. What happened? I don't like talking about it.
Jackie: Oh, yeah, especially when we're younger, definitely. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01: So be careful when you get your other friends involved, and you know, be mindful that they're not always on your side because they're maybe tired of listening to you. Give your friend give your friends the benefit of the doubt. Remember every remember, everyone is carrying something they you can't see. That's a very that goes around the internet quite a bit. You know, don't be so quick to judge. You don't know what I'm really going on in my life. And then, you know, stay curious longer than you're certain so that you don't make a conclusion and end your friendship and you know, give it some time to fix itself, to come to some agreement, to get past it, to let there be another ending that you didn't get.
SPEAKER_01: And sometimes even, and I've done it, I'm sure you've done it, Jackie too, in a friendship. You're almost certain what they're telling you is a lie, but it ends the fight. So you're like, okay, good, we'll live with that. Have you ever done that? Sure. You know what I mean? And sometimes give people grace. Go, okay, uh, you don't want to tell me. I don't want to tell you. Maybe you just got irritated. So let me give us this pass and we'll move on. Please, y'all. Yeah. Sometimes do that. I think it's important to do.
SPEAKER_01: Okay, Jack. So we want to go into bestie rapid questions. You go first.
Jackie: Okay, sure.
SPEAKER_01: Uh, let's see.
Jackie: Do you usually ask or assume?
SPEAKER_01: I guess I assume. I mean, I'm not sure.
Jackie: I assume, but I'm trying to ask more. I'm trying to ask more.
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah. I think it's a natural reaction to assume and to play the narrative because that's what we've always done. It's not a it's not a new thing. It's just an old way of dealing with something. And so it's hard to make it's hard to make changes in the way you've always dealt with something. So I just I'd like to be honest. I I do do assume sometimes. Sometimes I'm, you know, I'll ask. It just depends on the situation, of course. How dire emergency it is, if it's something we could just blow past, I probably won't spend too much time diving into it because it's not a it's not a total like gonna end our friendship and why do we need to hash it out?
SPEAKER_01: Why do women overthink friendships? Well, at some point the narrative turns into, and maybe it happens when we're not maybe not in grade school so much, but once we get in junior high and high school as women, we then become competitors, right? That's the same boy, we have the same friends. We we're out of the camaraderie into the into the competition. And there's no doubt the boys add to our problem, right? And that sometimes they have fueled that and they should have stayed out of it because they're trying to, you know, get with one girl, get with the other.
SPEAKER_01: And that girl said this. So I just think that sometimes those are imprinted in our minds because that's our growing years, and then we have this idea later in life. And I beg you to reconsider not everybody's your competition, they're not all trying to do do you in, but you can't have a real friendship unless you actually conclude that that's you know, that could be the truth. So just be mindful of it, y'all. All right, Jackie. Here's my question. What's the biggest mistake we make when we're hurt?
Jackie: I think overthinking and making rash decisions definitely you definitely overthink. I overthink everything. So that's my big biggest thing. And uh I I do make rash decisions. I'll say say things before I think it sometimes during the when I'm hurt. And like instead of sitting back and thinking about it before I say something, I say something too quick, and then it's like I should have said that.
SPEAKER_01: Right.
Jackie: How many people, how many times have we done that?
SPEAKER_01: I've definitely done that too. So all right, you have to ask you again because you asked me twice. What's one question? What's one question that can save a friendship?
Jackie: How I can better support you as a friend in this current season of your life. That's a good one, John.
SPEAKER_01: If you said that to me, I'd be like, thank you, because it it's coming with support, it's coming with how can I help you? And I can it'll put my guard down. If it was you and I, I would put my guard down because I'm like, she's wanting to help me. And so I think that's a really good one. That's a good one to say. So thank you. Kudos for you, John. And I mean it.
Jackie: I mean it. I mean it. I know. You evolved. That's what happened. Yeah. I know. But you will get some sarcastic remarks in the meantime, too. My backhanded ones, no. Right. Everybody is. What's something you've learned about assumptions as you've gotten older? Assumptions are silent stories. Your brain makes up to fill in missing facts.
SPEAKER_01: Yeah. So true, right? Yeah. Assumptions are made off of past experiences. And so we put we do what so often is we put that scenario into the current scenario and we screw up everything. And you know, you have to give people, you have to meet people on people's level that they are at. And, you know, there's some good, really good people out there. I know it's hard to decipher sometimes, but you screw up a really good friendship if you do that. So assumptions are makes asses out of you and me. Isn't there something in that when you assume you make an ass out of you and me?
Jackie: They feel like facts, but are actually wrong. They hurt your relationships, cause stress, and trap your mind in old habits, like you just said. Yeah. Right. Go back to what we're used to.
SPEAKER_01: Scenarios that don't really exist. So okay. I think one of the greatest lessons I've learned about friendship is that our minds are incredible storytellers. Sometimes those stories protect us, sometimes they prepare us, but sometimes they quietly steal relationships that never needed to end. Every friendship reaches a moment where something feels different. The question isn't what story can I tell myself? The question is, what conversation have I not had yet? Before you decide someone doesn't care, ask.
SPEAKER_01: Before you assume someone is angry, ask. Before you convince yourself the friendship is over, ask. Because the stories we tell ourselves can become so convincing we forget they're only stories. And sometimes the strongest friendship in our lives are saved, not by having all the answers, but having the courage to ask the one honest question.
Jackie: If this episode hit you in the fills or made you laugh way too hard, we consider that a win. If you enjoyed today's episode, we'd be so grateful if you'd subscribe, leave us a review, and share it with your ride or die best friend. Want to see some of the incredible friendships we've celebrated? Visit our Bestimony at YouTube channel where women from all over the country share their stories of friendships that changed their lives. And if one day you'd like to celebrate your own friendship, we'd love to welcome you to Nashville.
Jackie: Until next time, keep showing up, keep cheering each other on, keep celebrating the women who make life better. We'll see you next time on Slightly Unsupervised.
Song: We stick together, ride or die to the moon, and no amount of space could ever come between us two. Reuniting's like we never been apart, and every single time we add an eye and heart to heart.
Song: There's not enough for the spite.
Podbean